The short answer
What Illinois families should know.
Hearsay generally concerns an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of what it asserts. Illinois evidence rules contain exclusions and exceptions, but there is no general divorce exception allowing every text, letter, or secondhand account into evidence. The analysis starts with the specific statement and its intended use.
Ask what the statement is offered to prove
If a witness repeats another person’s claim to establish that the claimed event occurred, hearsay may be implicated. If the statement is offered for a different legitimate purpose, the analysis may differ. That purpose must be real and relevant, not a label applied to avoid the rule. Counsel should identify the factual proposition before deciding how to present the communication.
A party’s statement and a third party’s statement differ
Rule 801 treats specified statements offered against a party as nonhearsay. The same rule contains provisions expressly limited to criminal cases. A divorce is a civil proceeding, so borrowing a criminal-case rule can produce a wrong result. Preserve the speaker’s identity, complete context, and the circumstances of the communication so the proper category can be evaluated.
Exceptions require their own foundation
Rule 803 includes categories such as qualifying business records and certain statements made for treatment. The name of an exception is not enough. The circumstances must satisfy its requirements. An email from a professional or a note in a file may contain several speakers’ statements. Rule 805 requires each layer of combined hearsay to have an appropriate basis for admission.
Plan witnesses and records before the hearing
The best solution may be testimony from the person who observed the event, a properly supported record, or another admissible source. Do not assume that attaching a statement to a motion solves the problem. Give counsel complete communications and identify the people involved. Early preparation allows time to obtain witnesses and foundations rather than discovering at the hearing that the most important account is only secondhand.
Prepare
Useful next steps
- Identify the speaker and the exact fact each statement is meant to prove.
- Preserve complete messages and records with their context.
- Locate witnesses who personally observed the underlying events.
Avoid
Common missteps
- Assuming written statements are exempt from hearsay rules.
- Applying a criminal-only evidence provision to a civil divorce.
Continue reading
Related Illinois family-law guides.
Primary sources
Read the governing law and guidance.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Laws, court rules, local procedures, and individual facts can change the analysis. Reading it or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.